Steven Harris
“There’s Something in the Water” –
One day workshop on painting water at the Helotes Gallery.
June 26, 2023
Purposes of the Workshop
- Understanding what makes water look like it does
- Gaining tools to recreate those looks in paintings
The Workshop Plan
- Review some foundational ideas and
- Demonstrations of techniques for different types of water
- Oceans
- Rivers
- Lakes
- Wet surfaces/puddles
So … let’s begin:
Thinking about Painting Water Generally
- 1. First, the basics of my painting “process”.
- My process varies somewhat between “plein air” and studio painting primarily due to time constraints posed by changing light and portable equipment for painting outdoors versus what I can do with my outdoor setup versus my studio; however, some basics are always relevant.
- b. I often use a “toned ground” on my canvas. With water features, you have to be a bit more careful about toned grounds that might take your blues and greens toward grey and make the water look dull. You can change the toned ground to something like ultramarine blue to avoid this issue in water areas. A toned ground is especially useful in plein air painting where you are in a bit of a hurry, because it eliminates any white voids where canvas shows through the painting but underpainting is always effective to influence later layers of paint.
- c. As I begin, I sketch (blocking in) with solvent thinned (usually ultramarine blue) paint to set up my painting composition. At this stage I’m thinking about design, perspective, proportions and values. I’m not thinking about making a finished sketch of the scene. Use a big brush to keep out of the details.
- d. After I “block in”, I start painting my darkest dark masses (including in skies). I often go darker than I will end up painting. Remember this rule! “Dark to light”. It’s MUCH easier to paint light on dark wet on wet than dark on top of light. Once I have my big value areas blocked in, I can either proceed to middle value masses or do a little bit of highlighting to remind myself where they go. In these early stages I avoid using white as much as possible. White underpainting takes forever to dry and because it’s semi-opaque it tends to overpower your darks and cut the saturation in your lights at this early point where you want strong values. There is plenty of time later to adjust values and create highlights with mixtures including white. Now is not that time.
- e. This “block-in” stage ends only when I’m happy with the design and value selections.
- f. Up to now, I’ve been using thinned paint to speed up drying and to make myself focus on how I plan to paint on a more detailed level. That doesn’t mean going straight to the fine details. I’m working on larger masses and beginning to think about edges. Here I can start with stiffer paint (again going dark to light). This is where I’m “painting”. Gradually, I’ll focus more and more on finishing steps as the painting starts to take shape.
- g. “Stiff” versus “loose” paint. One last “process” point. Depending on the brand of paint (and color sometimes) your paint may be stiff or loose when it comes out of the tube. There are uses for both, but resist the urge to cut your paint out of the tube unless you have a purpose for doing so (like early stage sketching or toning). Once the blocked-in sketch is done and dry to the touch you can start to apply stiffer paint (again going dark to light). Stiff paint will normally go on over the initial thinned layer easily so long as your brushwork is correct. You want to avoid “scrubbing” what’s already on the canvas as you apply new paint unless you have a purpose for doing so – usually if you want to soften edges. The way to do this is to turn your brushes so they are not perpendicular to the work surface. You can also use medium SPARINGLY to loosen up paint in final stages to get smooth surfaces but if you paint “wet on wet” the medium will quickly remove the wet underpainting if you aren’t careful with brushwork.
- 2. A Useful Sequence in Painting Water
- a. Don’t paint the water!!!
- i. Paint the colors, values and design, but try to avoid letting your brain tell you to “paint the water” itself by just painting the surface of the water. It’s rare that you won’t be looking at a body of water that reveals multiple levels beneath its surface. That degree to which the underwater elements are revealed is dependent on several factors we discuss below, such as ambient light, water clarity, water motion and water depth. Often you aren’t just painting what you see; you are painting what makes it look the way it looks. Understanding this is probably the single most important key to painting water.
- ii. The water itself is typically a semi-transparent fluid when we paint rivers, lakes, oceans or puddles. Think about what happens when you put some seawater or lake water in a jar? It looks nothing like what you see in the body of water. This is because what you are really painting is mostly everything BUT the water itself.
- a. Don’t paint the water!!!
- b. Start with the overall design before you dive into the water.
- i. Is the water a focal point or a background? Do you want it to stand out or recede?
- ii. Think about foundational color choices and value relationships.
- iii. Think about transitions from dark to light in and around the water.
- iv. Think about composition and how the water body fits!
- v. Think about your “palette” for the whole painting because the water depends on a convincing harmony between the sky, land and water in terms of mood, light, weather and shadows.
- c. Whenever you do your water remember to go “dark to light” as you block it in.
- i. Put your tube of Titanium White back in the paint box!
- ii. Look “under” the highlights for the darks in the water. Paint them first.
- iii. “Fat over lean” matters a great deal when painting water. Thin darks and fatter highlights often give you depth and contrast. BUT DON’T DO THE HIGHLIGHTS TOO EARLY because you can end up with a muddy mess.
- d. Paint your water slowly and “have a plan” for painting it.
- i. Think about the geometry of your water design. Where are the darks and lights? Are you using perspective lines to gain depth? Are you breaking up lines? Are you thinking about edges?
- ii. It is CRITICAL to take your time and paint water in a deliberate sequence. If you don’t, you’ll end up again with a muddy mess more often than not.
- iii. Perspective in the water (water patterns get fatter and wider as they get closer) is important!
- iv. Pick a “focal point” in the water and work around that just like you do in the landscape. Your whole body of water is not one monotonous mass.
- 3. Let’s Talk About Water.
- a. The water you are painting is not one-dimensional.
- i. Ground planes are filled with opaque objects like buildings, trees and earth. Painting these objects is entirely different from painting water or skies. Yet there are things in the water that impact how the surface looks.
- ii. Water is its own “medium”. For example, the water in a swimming pool is (hopefully) clear – but you don’t see that; you see blue or blue/green because of the colors used to plaster the pool. Water “colors” itself with the things in its environment. Subsurface colors, movement, ambient lighting and the clarity of the water all play a role.
- iii. The surface of the water may be a flat plane like a lake on a calm day, or it may be agitated, like an ocean scene or a water fall or rapids. Currents beneath the surface may impact light reflection/refraction.
- iv. Depth changes in the water are very important to achieving a convincing painting. Often, these changes can become a highlight of the painting. The deeper the darker and calmer, as a general rule. Moreover, objects submerged in the water fade into the dark depths and shine in shallow depths when sunlight is present. Here, edge work and chroma can really help. Sharper edges and stronger colors on objects suggest something is close to the surface. Softer edges and duller/darker chroma says the opposite.
- v. You still need to handle water just like you do on the objects on ground planes or skies to make things recede into the distance as you approach the horizon with both linear and areal perspective. Lines get closer together, colors get bluer/softer and edges get softer. You can use objects in and under the water to provide useful “markers” or reference points. Because you don’t have the tools you do in landscapes (solid objects) to play to your perspective choices, the “design” of your water has to play that role, much like it does in sky scenes.
- a. The water you are painting is not one-dimensional.
- b. The water you are painting is the sum total of what you see on the surface and what you see beneath the surface.
- i. The images on the surface are distorted by reflection.
- ii. Things in/under the water are distorted by refraction.
- iii. Movement in the water (or lack of movement) may influence what you see too.
- iv. All of these things (reflection, reflection and movement) act as influences on how the water receives and reflects light.
- v. The visual image of water is strongly influenced by reflection and refraction in terms of what you see.
- c. Photographs are not always your friends. They distort scenes because they flatten the depth of field to make the “autofocus” feature work. Like photos of skies, water photographs suffer more because they miss all the hidden drivers your eyes can see in real life. Water almost always looks different in a photograph because the camera adjusts lighting to get balance just like it uses autofocus to flatten depth of field. Plein air painting teaches you this! Sketches (paintings or drawings) help you later interpret the photos you take.
- d. Perspective matters – a lot.
- i. You can sketch sight lines in your water as you block in to help you visualize your vanishing point and get a feel for proper scale. This design decision also dictates the angle of incidence between the viewer and the water by moving the horizon line up or down. Is it low, medium or high relative to the body of water. You might be looking down from a cliff, out from a beach, around you from a marshy spot or right out in the water.
- ii. Sight lines can be a useful tool to set the scene and influence distance, angle of incidence, or depth of field by the degree to which you force the viewer’s down or out or up. For example, many beginners paint rivers that end up looking like waterfalls because their sight lines are distorted. We’ll do some examples in class.
- iii. Water can utilize one-, two- or three-point perspective as well as “forced” perspective in which you exaggerate the sight lines to create depth of field.
- iv. In addition to linear perspective, we have to think about areal perspective in painting. Values and colors dim and trend toward blues as you look farther away in a body of water; especially a large one like the ocean. Effective use of value/color transitions can create depth that makes a simple seascape work.
- e. Abstraction as a tool in painting water
- i. One advantage in painting water – especially moving water like oceans or rivers - is that you don’t have to be as faithful to the actual scene and you can enhance the depth, movement, or drama of the scene.
- ii. Move, resize and relight elements in the water to suit your design.
- iii. Directional adjustments and choices about placement of solid objects, banks, bends and waives in your water scenes can add a lot to your painting.
- iv. I take lots of reference photos of water to use as material for paintings of completely different scenes.
- v. Abstraction helps you avoid trying to “render” a scene, but it only works if you keep things in the right perspective/proportions.
- Reflections. Water reflects objects nearby with varying degrees of strength depending on lighting, water movement wind, and the size of the objects in reflection.
- i. There is much more to painting reflections than simply duplicating what is on the shoreline “upside down” in the water!
- ii. Some basic ideas:
- Reflections are normally lighter and less saturated (chroma) than the object on land.
- Brights/whites will go gray in reflections and darks will have a value shift toward lighter.
- Make these shifts with color!!! Not with white or black/blue/brown paint used just to darken things. The grays used for adjusting values in water should relate to the base colors being used in the sky and water. Example, if you sky is a strong blue and water is a similar blue, greys should run blue, not brown or black or green. If your water is more greenish, greys should run green/blue rather than red, brown or black.
- Water is more dense than air, so it absorbs light more efficiently. This means you must take care not to “match” sky and water values. Water is almost always darker than sky.
- Edges will soften relative to the object on land. Hard edges in reflections must be limited to minor notes here and there – if at all.
- Like edges, details must be softened or eliminated.
- Use surface features (waves or ripples) to blur or break edges.
- How light impacts water
- i. Light comes in (and is then reflected out or refracted) at an angle depending on the location of the light source relative to the object it strikes. The angle of incidence is equal to the angle of reflection but they travel in different directions. (See above).
- ii. In water, like skies, these angles vary by time of day/season because the sun moves both horizontally and vertically (higher warmer skies in summer and lower cooler in winter) – so summer and winter lighting can be noticeable in paintings of water.
- iii. The angles of incidence and reflection/refraction affect color and light (and temperature) on any surface the light meets. Light at high noon is often referred to as “flat light” because it is strong and often cooler, but unable to create as many effects because the angles of incidence and reflection/refraction are very narrow. Shadows and highlights at mid-day are much less interesting. If you watch really good movies (in terms of the photography and art direction) you can see what a difference strong lighting choices can make.
- iv. Interference with the light source can also impact the scene.
- v. Back-lit scenes with warmer light result from the sun being closer to the horizon where the atmosphere influences the light.
- vi. The colors and lighting of the sky and water change as light recedes because the angles of incidence/reflection and the intensity of the light change. Sunlight from over your shoulder is more intense right above you than it is on the horizon. The reverse is true when the sun is setting behind the horizon.
- vii. Because of all of this the “Golden Hour” is that time after sunrise/before sunset when we have great lighting effects in landscapes.
- viii. Remember that you may also have varying intensity of light due to density changes in clouds that impact form and cast shadows and highlights.
- h. The importance of identifying light source(s)
- i. The sun may or may not be the only light source. Others include reflected light from water or objects and artificial light in the scene.
- ii. Once you identify your light source(s), keep reminding yourself where your predominant light source is as you paint. This enables you to get coloring, shadows and highlights right. If you lose track of your light source and end up with colors wrong or shadows or highlights in the wrong places, nothing works!
- iii. If you’re painting from a reference photo, this is especially important because it’s not always obvious from the photo. A piece of painters’ tape indicating the direction from which light is coming can help in early stages of a painting from a photo.
- i. Setting the right temperature
- i. It is critical that your sky, land and water show compatible temperatures and value ranges.
- ii. The direction, intensity and temperature of the prevailing light dictates how objects (land, sky and water) must look to retain their depth and value relative to the rest of the painting. If the sky, land and water don’t harmonize, the painting will look unrealistic.
- iii. Examples of lighting changes that impact painting choices:
- 1. Sunset/sunrise coloring and lighting,
- 2. “Flat” light mid-day,
- 3. Evening lighting.
- iv. Seasonal changes where the sun is lower in the sky all day (winter) or higher (summer) result in brighter/dimmer and warmer/cooler light.
- j. Painting waves. Why edges matter so much
- i. Waves in water (big or small) are structures with rounded breaks in the surface that are rough or smooth (or both) depending on conditions. More often than not, they are also translucent to a degree and backlighted. To achieve these effects, you have to understand how waves are built, and why lighting and edges are critical.
- ii. First, the structure: *
- iii. Then, the lighting:
- iv. The fronts of waves tend to be hard edged compared to the backs – but use variety with edges that are “hard”, “soft” or “lost” create depth and separation in clouds.
- v. Edges create depth by adding or deleting lines that interrupt the eye.
- vi. “Dark to Light” is absolutely essential here. You must paint the darker interior forms first. Paint the middle values next and then – only then – the lighter values and foam/highlights.
- vii. Little waves and ripples are edge dependent. Here are some “Galveston” waves that aren’t big enough to get the dramatic effects that you see in the painting above:
And a scene from the “bay” side of Galveston showing nothing more than the tidal current:
- viii. Regardless of the kinds of waves at the beach, the colors must change as you get closer to the beach because the water is becoming shallower and the waves are being flattened.
- ix. Another viewpoint – from above – shows the effects of sudden shallowness in the sea floor in a plein air piece I did in Ireland:
- x. Waves often have a hard edge on one side (that one that wants to break) and soft edges on the other side (the back side that is really just rolling toward the front side.
- xi. Bigger waves are round-ish and more importantly semi-transparent/translucent with lighting from the back side in many cases combined with shadows from the wave tops. So, … you aren’t painting the wave, you are painting the colors coming through the wave body.
- xii. I have some diagrams for this.
- k. Painting moving water
- i. Here, the focus must turn to how to convey movement in shallow streams. Broken color, directional brush work and value changes work well for this:
You can “slow” the movement down with your use of perspective, design and brushwork while still using broken color to convey the changes in water depth:
- l. Using color combinations
- i. You can spend the rest of your life studying color theory and painting swatches. Meantime, there are some basic rules of thumb however.
- ii. These combinations are important because shadows and highlights must read together and not fight one another.
- 1. Greys are critical in water just like in skies/clouds – but here again, temperature is critical. There are warm and cool greys and there are greys with roots in blues, blacks, browns, greens, reds and yellows. Think about compliments as you mix to get the grey you want.
- 2. Your blues must also work in harmony with the scene.
- 3. Little touches of accents (reds, sienna, yellow, orange) can work wonders after you’ve laid in the basic water you want.
- iii. You can see these ideas at work in any good painting. They convey mood/light/season/time of day and weather through value and color choices. Sunrises or sunsets differ from mid-day and dawn/dusk scenes are much cooler as the sun recedes behind the horizon.
- m. Broken color
- i. This is one of my favorite techniques in water painting. You avoid mixing certain passages on the canvas when combining different values/shades to “make the eye” work when viewing the painting. This was a key in the impressionists’ work and it’s used often today.
- ii. Broken color is especially effective in combination with stronger passages of solid or smooth color that imply depth or stillness while the broken color suggests shallow, rocky or moving stream flows.
- n. Brushwork matters too
- i. Brushwork tells the eye which direction to go. Done with some planning and care it can reinforce perspective and design. Done carelessly it can defeat the whole design. Think about brush work as you approach elements of the design:
- 1. Am I working on edges or larger masses?
- 2. Is my brush direction right?
- 3. Is my brush angle right?
- 4. Is my brush pressure right?
- 5. Do I want smooth, rough or in-between surface when paint is applied?
- 6. Am I painting thick or thin layer?
- 7. How am I loading my brush? Thin/thick/mixed/unmixed paint
- ii. Don’t “lick” the water with your brush! Make deliberate strokes and careful choices – SLOWLY and paint with intention. Don’t go over the same spot repeatedly.
- iii. Slow down. The object is not to finish fast or to keep moving your brush constantly; it’s to do things in a “painterly” way. You aren’t painting a fence and you aren’t in a race to see how fast you can paint.
- iv. Mix colors with your knife on the palette before you load the brush. Don’t use the brush as a mixer because pretty soon it will have every color on your palette in the bristles and the painting becomes muddy. Besides, mixing with your knife lets you “test” a mix against the painting as you go – like a color chip – without putting any paint on the canvas.
- v. Brushwork also involves choices about handling your paint. Sometimes, a little medium is useful to get a smooth even coat. Often, unaltered paint on the brush works well to get a looser “painterly” look or a highlight. Remember, the paint behaves differently on the surface depending on whether you are cutting it with a medium.
- vi. Finally, remember that your brush has a “reverse gear” and an edge and bristles that mix/scrape/smooth/scratch depending on your approach. It also responds to the “angle of incidence” where it meets the canvas. All of your brush handling matters like a musician using a bow or a drum stick. Brushes behave differently if they’re pulled, pushed, dragged or scumbled. They’re supposed to. The effects can be amazing.
- i. Brushwork tells the eye which direction to go. Done with some planning and care it can reinforce perspective and design. Done carelessly it can defeat the whole design. Think about brush work as you approach elements of the design: